The Arcadia Project: Down The Black Lace Rabbit Hole [part 3]

arcadia the promise cover art
Side two only had one single, but it was a great one

[…continued from this post]

“Missing” was the only song of this project that existed in Simon LeBon’s notebooks prior to Nick Rhodes calling him up and telling him that he wasn’t going on a holiday for six months, but was going to make an album with him instead. While the rest of this album was written as it was recorded, this was the single pre-existing piece. Ironically, the recording of it on the album was the track there that was the most redolent of improvisation. The arrangement was daring in its complete lack of drums. Never had Duran Duran ventured down this road before, but the co-producer Alex Sadkin had the bright idea or recording the song mostly live, with David Van Tiegham, Masami Tuschiya, and Mark Egan playing live in the studio with Simon in the vocal booth and Nick in the control room. Never had members of Duran Duran sounded so organic and impressionistic.

The guitar and fretless bass harmonics drifted like gas in the undefined space. The sound would be picked up later in Duran Duran on tracks like “The Edge Of America,” hit it was never really bettered than on this song. The tenor sax overdubs from Andy MacKay of Roxy Music were impeccably placed with great care. All of the track was definitely a case of less being more, as it gave mixer Larry Alexander [ironically an engineer from the Power Station studio] a chance to emphasize dubspace beauty that seemed as evanescent as the morning dew.

The beginning of side two began with a brief instrumental to act as an intermezzo for the album. “Rose Arcana” was only 50 seconds of palate cleansing but I loved how Van Tiegham added percussion highlights that sounded like flocks of birds taking flight as Nick Rhodes explored a lurching, sampled ambiance underscored by Mark Egan’s fretless bass. It set the stage perfectly for what wast to immediately follow.

The introduction of “The Promise” was deceptively small and finely etched as a sequencer loop danced like a waterbug on a pond’s surface for all of eight seconds before the song’s raison d’être hit with the force of a pile driver as peals of David Gilmour’s achingly beautiful guitar chords arced over the horizon of the song like birds heading into the sun. Simon’s wordless expression vocals, echoing their vibe.

Then when he began singing, his phrasing and timing was held back to hang back behind the beat to draw the listener into his web. While often his lyrical turns were cause for eye-rolling, one could not say that at this time. This song was a powerhouse on every level, and indicative of the caliber of this project that it featured a certain Sting on backing vocals.

At the Band Aid sessions, Nick Rhodes has noted how well that LeBon and Sting harmonized together and so the call went out to Sting, who was then prepping his big solo splash from The Police. Yet he found the time to add his turn here, as did Herbie Hancock. Let me say that all of the firepower her was fully utilized at the very highest level of accomplishment. The sound of “The Promise” was fully realized in the expression of what Arcadia were striving for. This was nothing of not some of the most beautiful music of the not very beautiful musical year of 1985.

In fact, the only comparable album project was Bryan Ferry’s solo album, “Boys + Girls” album. His first recording to follow the seminal “Avalon.” Like “So Red The Rose” it was another of those “no expense spared” albums with the cream of session players adding their magic. And wouldn’t you know it, David Gilmour also figured in that opus as well! I can imagine the phone calls from the Arcadia and Ferry camps to Gilmour’s management, with the bidding war leaving Gilmour laughing all the way to the bank. With the performance stamped on this song, he deserved every Pound. And it must have thrilled Rhodes to be competing with Ferry for the same resource. Plus, Arcadia netted Andy MacKay as well!

Every second of this album was dripping with sophistication and élan. When David Gilmour returned in the coda to solo with Egan and the band playing a call and response with MacKay, Van Tiegham, and Carlos Alomar joining in, it was a joy to hear. The 7:30 song more than earned its length with our applause.

Next: …Giving The Devil Some Ice

About postpunkmonk

graphic design | software UI design | remastering vinyl • record collector • satire • non-fiction
This entry was posted in Assorted Images, Core Collection, New Romantic, Record Review, Your Prog Roots Are Showing and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to The Arcadia Project: Down The Black Lace Rabbit Hole [part 3]

  1. jsd says:

    good call out the “boys & girls” comparison. both albums inhabit a similar universe. i love it. wish there was more of this style from the era but i guess it was out of the budgetary reach of most.


  2. JT says:

    While we’re on a DD subject, I just saw that they have a new single, with an album due October 22.
    Seems better than their previous effort, but not as good as All You Need Is Now. Maybe back into Red Carpet territory.


  3. Bridget says:

    I bought the CD based on the cover and your write-up. I have been listening to it over the weekend….wow. The Roxy Music influence is very evident. I love the songs “Promise” and “El Diabo.” When I think about when this was recorded, I am amazed at the quality and variety of sound that was used in the music. When the lyric in the “Promise” is about “heaven closes it eyes” (I think that’s it) it is so beautiful and ethereal. In ‘El Diablo’, they mix the Andean pipes (I lived in Ecuador for a brief bit) and jazzy notes.

    In “Rio” my favorite song was “The Chauffeur” and this album seems to expand on the interesting lyrics and sounds in that song. I seem to remember now that I would buy an album for the ‘hit’ song but if it was a great album, I ended up liking other songs better, usually in the middle or last bits of the album. This one is in that genre as well, for me.

    I love that we can buy singles now and build playlists so easily, however, it used to be you had to take a chance on the album being a dud or just repetitious crap and a waste of money in the end. The artists I appreciate were those who saw the whole album as a way to showcase many different songs and variations. They were true craftsmen or artists.

    Thanks for bringing this great album to my belated attention!


    • postpunkmonk says:

      Bridget – So happy to be of service! Wow! You managed to track down a CD? I’m impressed. This one was a keeper for sure. It was the culmination of a certain thread running through the early Duran Duran material [as you adroitly pointed out] that was probably the reason why I became a fan in the first place. Taken here to a high degree that might only be bettered with a song like “Land” a few years down the line. The band could have an Art Rock thread running through the material just as much as the Dance Pop they made their fortune with and here, at least, the Dance Pop was shown the door.


  4. Steve says:

    The album is just a winner. Terrible shame it is relatively overlooked. Home run for me I love David Gilmour, Roxy and Duran. Lovely write-up.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.