Record Review: Iggy Pop – The Idiot US CD [part 1]

iggy pop the idiot 1990 US CD cover

Virgin ‎| US | CD | 1990 | 2-91342

Iggy Pop: The Idiot US CD [1990]

  1. Sister Midnight
  2. Nightclubbing
  3. Funtime
  4. Baby
  5. China Girl
  6. Dum Dum Boys
  7. Tiny Girls
  8. Mass Production

It’s been 42 years, but in the waning days of 2019, I finally got around to hearing Iggy Pop’s “The Idiot.” It’s not like I haven’t known the album by reputation for 40 years! As a big fan of Bowie’s albums made around the same time, this was a grievous omission. The cold hard fact was that one of the first gifts I can remember my wife giving me was an LP [German, I think] of “The Idiot” but when I tried to play it the album skipped. She had gotten it for me at Rock + Roll Heaven and there was some notion of taking it back and getting another copy but this never happened though I remember discussing this with owner Ray Ehmen’s brother.

The LP of “The Idiot” has been in my Record Cell for over 20 years. The truth of the matter is that unless I have a CD of a title, I usually never listen to it. Records are a hassle. So I went an inordinate number of years before running into a CD of “The Idiot” at Earshot in Winston-Salem two weeks ago. It was there. A used CD at a good price [$6.00] so I bought it without hesitation. The following Monday, I played it in the car going to work and it sounded really compelling. That’s about all I have been listening to for the last two weeks on my work commute. As soon as it finished it began playing again and there really wasn’t anything else that I wanted to hear more, so I let it loop. In spite of the title, it seems like I was “the idiot. ” Why else would I have not bought a copy of this at least by 1982 when I was all over “Low” and “Heroes?” Because this album was just as good as either of them! Perhaps more so, because this was the template that gave those albums a foundation to be built upon.

iggy pop - sister midnight german single coverThis was apparent immediately up front when “Sister Midnight” got underway. The track [indeed, the whole album] had music written by producer David Bowie who admitted that he was using his writing/production of “The Idiot” as a dry run for what ideas he was interested in pursuing on his next album, “New Music Night And Day,” which eventually was released with the title “Low.” That meant that melodic development was minimized. Monolithic Krautrock repetition [ala Neu] was maximized. Many of these songs could have been constructed from loops if that was more common in the dying days of 1976 when this album was recorded.

What the ear noticed immediately after the repetition was the drum sound. This was the first use of the Eventide Harmonizer H910 to slur the drums with a downward pitch on the decay and this was gated for further effect. Tony Visconti, who only mixed “The Idiot,” has long taken claim for introducing Bowie and Eno to the technique on “Low” but the fact remains that “The Idiot” was recorded prior to “Low” and Visconti presumably came in on the back end of things when mixing happened. But Visconti hasn’t gone on record as to whether he originated the sound on “The Idiot” or not. In any case, the harmonized drum sound served to further abstract drums into sounding more machine like. Almost prefiguring the Simmons Drum sound of four years later. Harmonized drums may have even been an influence on the sound design of the Simmons chips. That would be a good question for Richard James Burgess one day.

The propulsion for the repetitive track was down to the rhythm guitar hook played by Carlos Alomar; the man who got co-writing credit here and on Bowie’s hit “Fame” thanks to his indelible sense of timing and structure as well as his ability to render it intrinsic to the arrangement of the song. As for the singer, Iggy affected his lowest baritone while Bowie doubled him on falsetto for a bracing effect. Split octave vocals where a voice is doubled either above or below an octave from the foreground is an effective technique for generating otherness; but here there were two octaves between the voices for an even more profoundly disquieting effect. And as Iggy progressed through the song, his composure gradually unravelled.

At the song’s midpoint, Pop recounted an oedipal dream that he had as the song [unfortunately] makes a connection with “The End” by The Doors. Iggy Pop had always been massively influenced by Jim Morrison [to the extent that he eventually owned a pair of the singer’s famous leather pants] and this has always been a thing I have needed to endure while being as big of an Iggy Pop fan as I am. I can’t say the same about Morrison. But it was on the next verse that Pop completely dispensed with any remaining cool as he ultimately devolved into making animalistic noises in the song’s coda while the mutant Krautrock-cum-reggae groove lurched into the sunset.

Next: …Brand New Dances



About postpunkmonk

graphic design | software UI design | remastering vinyl • record collector • satire • non-fiction
This entry was posted in Bowie, Record Review and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Record Review: Iggy Pop – The Idiot US CD [part 1]

  1. Gavin says:

    Gosh,you were even later to the Idiot Party than I was-I bought it on cassette in the early 90s then later on cd.
    I am not a big fan of Jimmy O by any means,but this album is monumental and an essential part of my collection (and education).
    The influence/contributions of The Dame is felt strongly and I adore his sax playing on this album,whatever anyone says!


  2. Echorich says:

    It’s the energy generated on The Idiot that I am most drawn to. It’s an energy that Bowie obviously needed going into his own next work and it makes it, for me, the fourth “Berlin Album.”


    • postpunkmonk says:

      Echorich – Interesting that you use the word energy. When I hear “The Idiot,” I hear a void. The absence of energy. I feel a palpable vacuum. It’s like a musical black hole. I think that “Lodger” should be exiled into one-off territory and “The Idiot” should be first in the sequence with “Low” and “Heroes” following. Then we have an arc that makes a lot of sense to me.


      • In the context of the influence of Berlin on this and the other albums in the “trilogy,” I get what you’re saying here, Monk — but gosh by golly, I think Lodger is a terrific album and shouldn’t be exiled anywhere (even one-off land, since it’s my view that it is perfectly paired with Scary Monsters).


      • Echorich says:

        I think the energy of which I speak isn’t so much physical as much as artistic. It’s dark, sexual, martial, chemically impaired, but it is an undeniable energy.


  3. Ade.W says:

    I have just had a listen to “The idiot” and “lodger” back to back. Neither are among my favourite listens. I find “the idiot” a bit tough going, it has an odd sound to it, my copy is an LP, I might try a CD version but they all seem to be 1ST generation. Turgid is good word to describe it, poor old Ian Curtis listening to that album, listening to Mass Production !!!! As for lodger, well putting it on straight after , it seems a bit better than I remember, of course its saved by its singles. The last track “Red Money” could fit right onto “The idiot”


    • postpunkmonk says:

      Ade.W – Well “Red Money” is “Sister Midnight” with new lyrics, so there’s that. Turgid may be a word that describes “The Idiot.” I’d personally choose something less negative like “oppressive” to describe it. It’s an album without much hope at all; shot through with fatalism. But I view that as its strength.


  4. SimonH says:

    You must try the live versions on the live at the Royal Albert Hall blu ray, amazing stuff!

    Liked by 1 person

    • postpunkmonk says:

      SimonH – No BluRay® for me. I’m still on analog CRT playback! I have the DVD version on the Infinite Want List®. Great set list on that show! I only saw Iggy on the “Beat ‘Em Up” tour in 2001 but at least there’s that!


  5. SimonH says:

    Any format will do. I was at the RAH gig and I would say it’s in my top 5 gigs ever, and that’s a lot of gigs over 38 years!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.