Record Review: Stephen Duffy – I Love My Friends DLX RM [part 3]

[…continued from last post]

Now we get to the crux of the matter. No matter how proper it was to hear the original album that Duffy wanted to release, I had the two “new” songs on singles as B-sides. What made this DLX RM a must-have was the bonus disc of demos culled by Duffy himself from his archives entitled “Blown Away: Selected Demos vol. 1.” This implies we might eventually get a volume 2 one day! The timespan for these demos runs through at least the last 30 years, so some of these were possibly from the late period of The Lilac Time, phase one. After a musique concrète intro [similar to the one that had begun the main album] the title track was perhaps, the most evasive song here. The melody resisted easy listening but since it was written after Duffy’s father had died, in his mother’s loft, that probably explains that rare melodic lapse from Duffy. He was probably not in the mood for ear candy.

Which probably accounts for the abrupt shift of vibe for “The Whole Earth Singing.” The vocal harmonies here were sublime, but the juxtaposition amid the strummed acoustics and electric guitars musically suggested none other than the group America! Yeah, this would slot in nicely with “Sister Golden Hair” were it not for the perceptive and witty meta-lyrics about the joy of well-sung harmonies. It’s undoubtedly got that 70s AM radio vibe down cold enough to give me a whiff of cognitive dissonance. For a demo, this one sounds like it’s using all 12 tracks on Duffy’s Akai unit.

“C’est La Vie, C’est La Guerre” was eventually the B-side to “Natalie” but the version here was more stripped down and like most of the songs here, was probably down to just Duffy and his tape deck. This version has managed to work it’s way into my consciousness more effectively for its simplicity allowing the melody to embed itself in my cranium. In fact, it’s been there all weekend. “Go” was another more fully arranged song that seemed to bring to mind some Lilac Time memories. Duffy wrote that the song dated from 1993 when he was holed up in Alaska [?] awaiting the end of his Parlophone contract.

The next track was from the writing period of “Paradise Circus” and “Suburban Symphony” was written at the same time as “If The Stars Shine Tonight,” which got all of the love until now. One can easily imagine this on the second Lilac Time album which had raised the stakes over their more spartan debut. The song had a darkly beautiful air to it that flirted with pop only to retreat if not to the shadows to the penumbra of them. The synth drone coupled with the flutes [or are those a mellotron?] gave this a more full bodied arrangement that proved to be a nice variation for the collection, which was mostly Duffy and guitar alone.

“Another Golden Shot” was more straightforward with the twangy guitar being an outlier to the country music album that Duffy never made. Two more previously heard songs figured here in demo form, making the toll for this album three songs that we had heard earlier in B-side form. “The Waitress’ Story” was another winsome folk-rock piece and it as well as “The Girl Of The Year” had both surfaced on the “London Girls” single from Duffy’s eponymous album period of 1995. The latter sported some organ fills to justify it 5:30 length. “Lupin” was a mostly instrumental that would have felt right at home on the Lilac Time debut. “We Continue For Australasia” was another BBC world service soundbite and not a song.

“Blown Away” was a eventful dive into the deep bag of demos Duffy has in his archives. The timespan on these was all over the place, but he picked the songs not to document a span of time but to make an album that cohered as a unit. If anything, the album stuck together even more strongly than “I Love My Friends,” which was much more eclectic. But as rewarding as “Blown Away” was, it really didn’t hold a candle to the songs on “I Love My Friends.” Even the first version of the album in 1998 seemed to be some sort of a breakthrough for Duffy in that the immediacy of his writing was entering a new plateau. The time for cagey or florid metaphor had passed and now, it seemed, that his guard had been lowered.

We found out in the liner notes here that there had been a strong reason for this. By 1994, Duffy had begun to unravel with a diagnosis of depression. As a result, he entered into Jungian therapy and started to tear away the walls of artifice that had heretofore been a part of his songs. The changes were immediately if naively apparent to me in 1998 and this is perhaps why this album became one of my go-to Duffy recordings in the last 20 years. We are lucky that there seems to have been in retrospect, an impressive program of DLX RMs of Duffy albums such as:

that have seen many of them getting the love and attention with bonus tracks, but none so liberally as this one, where he managed to sneak in a completely new album while restoring his original vision for this one to its glory. For a fascinating interview with Duffy on this project check out the page here.

– 30 –

About postpunkmonk

graphic design | software UI design | remastering vinyl • record collector • satire • non-fiction
This entry was posted in Core Collection, Record Review and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Record Review: Stephen Duffy – I Love My Friends DLX RM [part 3]

  1. Tim says:

    Sadly underwhelmed with the Duffy commentary response.
    Did you see the documentary made about him several years back? There appears to be no release of it on physical media. There is a related…..I don’t think one may call it soundtrack…..but a collection of music released contemporary to the documentary. It looks like an interesting collection and sadly the music is attributed to both him and the Lilac Time. Even worse said cd is out of print and appears to command a hefty price (while containing some content exclusive to it).


    • postpunkmonk says:

      Tim – That’s typical when we are talking about Stephen Duffy; the essence of a highly respected cult artist. I know. The “Memory + Desire” project may have only had a few festival showings in pre-final form. Sad about the CD as well. Things like that drive me batty. The Duffy interview I linked to states that they only sold 500 copies of “Runout Groove.” Scandalous! But his profile is so low, that copies are not yet expensive.


  2. Tim says:

    The kicker is that one may buy the Memory & Desire companion album as a mp3 download via Amazon UK but not via Amazon US. Love those business models where folks are not able to buy money and support the artist because they live on the wrong side of the planet. Home taping is killing music, you know!


  3. Tim says:

    A little 6 Degrees of Separation with Stephen Duffy….
    Saint Etienne followed through on their threat to release the Tapestry disk from the new Tiger Bay deluxe as a digital download, I bought mine via Amazon, not sure about iTunes.
    Track 3 is a vocal track that Stephen Duffy recorded for Western Wind, a very spartan, almost acapella track,
    The bad news about this album of sketches is that it will set you back $12 and the running time is under 23 minutes. The good news is that as Saint Etienne eps go this one is quite good. I know it’s not saying much but miles better than Places to Visit, for example.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.