Simple Minds @ The Tabernacle – Atlanta 10-8-18 [part 2]

They did it again! Simple Minds began the show with a fantastic new song instead of older material.

[continued from last post]

When I had last seen Simple Minds, in 2013, they pulled a rabbit out of their hat by starting the show with “Broken Glass Park,” a vibrant new song I didn’t expect. This time they were touring behind their best album since 1983, so naturally, they pulled the top quality “Signal And The Noise” out of their quiver of songs first. The song was a hugely successful throwback to the driving, motorik sound of “Sons + Fascination” coupled with a tremendous lyric that would have been alien to the abstract imagery they favored back then, so naturally we all immediately got very excited! There’s nothing wrong with giving your best shot right up front, is there?

Charlie Burchill – guitar hero

Like the 2013 show, they then followed this up with the expansive statement of intent that was “Waterfront.” Either Charlie or Gordon Goudie triggered the bass loop [they each had synths adjacent] and then we were off and bouncing. If ever there was a song made for live performance, it’s this one with its monolithic, four-to-the-floor beat and its series of crescendoes that plateau ever upward. Then the distinctive random wave intro of what could only be “Love Song” hit the PA and we were treated to the first of the hits from what we’ll call the Monk-zone of Minds fandom that pre-dated “New Gold Dream [81, 82, 83, 84].” This is one of my top Simple Minds songs but tonight the energy was not focused. The lack of a dedicated keyboard player as well as [I’m going to say it] the recent experience of the acoustic tour has apparently rubbed off on the band to its detriment. Both Charlie and Gord Goudy had synth rigs onstage, but that meant that sometimes Charlie split between synths and lead guitar and Goudy did the same with his acoustic guitars.

Now this wasn’t the fully acoustic performance like “Speed Your Love To Me” had been in the soundcheck; the song had the vibrancy of rock music, but what I found critical to the potency of “Love Song” was the doubling of the guitars and synths together on the iconic riff. In every other performance of this song I had seen, it had all of the impact that the song has always had in listening to the album version. Tonight, the lack of synths piling on that riff led to the dissipation of its energy. So while it wasn’t a flat out disaster, it did stand as weak as compared to the last two shows I had seen where they had played it in 2002 and 2013.

This band was tailor made for cherry picking the cream of the “Real Life” album

Next, something happened that was shocking to me. The last time I had seen the band they leaned heavily on their breakthrough “Once Upon A Time” album with five of its eight songs played. That I still had a thrilling time was down to everything else about the set. That would not happen this evening. Instead, other albums that had been under represented in the live sets I had seen would get the nod. I’m not crazy about “Real Life” but I did think that there was an EP worth of goods there. One of the songs from that album that delivered was “Let There Be Love,” which I had not had the pleasure of hearing live before. This version of the band were well suited to do it up right, with new drummer Cherisse Osei backing off from the John Bonham-influenced Mel Gaynor sound for something a little more dynamic. There were four songs from that album that stood apart from the mishaps. Would I hear more of them tonight?

Charlie and Sarah

From that nice surprise, the band worked their way backward, skipping the troubling middle 80s period of the band for something that built on the platform that “Let There Be Love” provided and took the energy higher. Much higher. Good gravy, it’s hard to believe, but I have never heard this band lay into the propulsive “Up On The Catwalk” live before! Until this evening! They really scored a goal with this one! This gave Ms. Osei a change to really work out the chunky rhythms so crucial to the song’s success.

Then, afterward, Jim Kerr brought her to the front of the stage and introduced her to the audience. It’s fascinating to see this band incorporate women, especially women of color, into their makeup with no regard for conventions or expectations. I’m up for anything as long as the band honor their sound or build on it in coherent ways. Kerr asked Osei what her favorite song from the “Walk Between Worlds” album was and she replied “A Sense Of Discovery.” The band then played the dreamlike track, which cheekily incorporated the bridge vocal structure of “Alive + Kicking” into what I found to be a much better song. Charlie has a great solo on this one and for once, Goudy’s acoustic guitars had a welcome place here where they made more sense. They then launched into a version of “Promised You A Miracle” that felt a little diffuse without the heavy synths that the original recording was so heavily dependent on. Truth be told, the arrangement here seemed to recall the version of “Live In The City Of Lights.” The last two times I had seen the band, they had not made that choice, but at least they kept the energy level of the song up without the unnecessary downbeat coda of that 1986 version of the song.

“The American” really gets the Monk blood pumping!

They next dipped in to The Monk Zone for “The American.” I was fantastically excited to hear this finally in 2013 and tonight was not any different! This song was tailor made for chanting along to the brilliant chorus and I was thrilled that Mr. Ware, who was next to me, was hearing it with me this time. I should mention that the audience were standing [as you can see in the shots of the show] all night long, so we tried our best not to careen into our adjacent spouses. That’s hard to do when your favorite band [did I just say that?] is playing one of your top three songs and doing a great job of it. My only regret was that they played the 7″ version since less than seven minutes on this one always feels like a tease!

Next: …New Peaks Ahead

About postpunkmonk

graphic design | software UI design | remastering vinyl • record collector • satire • non-fiction
This entry was posted in Concert Review, Core Collection, Scots Rock and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Simple Minds @ The Tabernacle – Atlanta 10-8-18 [part 2]

  1. Echorich says:

    Let be begin by saying, I went, I danced, I sang along, I was surprised at times, and enjoyed myself thoroughly in the company of my old and new friends…

    It really is a stroke of both bravado and genius to put you best foot forward in concert. SM did this in 2013 with Broken Glass Park and repeated it for us with The Signal And The Noise. The build up of the band into the song is just perfect as an opener. Kerr lets you know that vocally he still means business 40 years on.
    I did everything I could to not know what prior show set lists contained but somehow I Travel had leaked through to my eyes on someone’s Fakebook page. So it was with some surprise and much disappointment that we weren’t treated to that urgent Post Punk Classic.
    I fully agree that Love Song was just missing that something special. For me, it was just ok. Without the upfront synth/guitar layers, Love Song is a very stripped down repetitive song. Give a “Rock” rendering live, it loses those nuances that made it the Post Punk Dance masterpiece that it was.
    It was interesting hearing Let There Be Love. I didn’t mention this to anyone at the time, but I really prefer Iva Davies/Icehouse’s Berlin Tapes version. I completely understand why Davies chose it for that collection – he was meant to sing it.
    Following up with Up On The Catwalk was the first really personal note for me. On any given day, I may say UOTC is my favorite Simple Minds song. It goes against all of my passion for SM’s Sons And Fascination/Sister Feelings Call era, but there is a poetic urgency, an emotional energy that Simple Minds tapped into that has always stood out for me. Besides, in the era of Big Music, Simple Minds just completely shut down any other bands’ attempts (you know of whom I speak) with Sparkle In The Rain.
    Monk, you and I are of one mind with Sense Of Discovery, for me this is one of a number of songs on Walk Between Worlds which seem an attempt to right some of the wrongs of Once Upon A Time. OUAT failed because the band put so much pressure on themselves and the music to be a chart success, only to have it supplanted by the international hit they had with “that John Hughes song.”
    By now it was obvious that this was the lean/mean Simple MInds onstage so when Promised You A Miracle turned into a sing a long rather than synth and bass tour de force from New Gold Dream, it wasn’t too much of a surprise.
    The American seems like a welcome friend, having now heard it two tours in a row. It is a bulletproof Simple Minds song from a bulletproof era in their career. I sang the chorus at the top of my lungs.
    Let me close this comment by saying that Ged Grimes went a very long way to making me thing Derek who? while I was entranced by is aggressive bass playing.


  2. zoo says:

    I admit that I haven’t kept up to date on all the line up changes. I knew Mel was no longer around, but when did they ditch the full-time keyboard player? Seems like a crime, IMO!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.