I had played the tape I’d made of “Earthling” on the trip to South Florida to minimal response. It was only the second time I had listened to it, for that matter. We arrived at the venue and immediately set about finding someone who wanted a ticket. Many wanted two, but after ten minutes, one lucky person walked away with a ticket and we had an extra $40 in our pocket. It was twilight as they began letting people into the modest venue. We jockeyed for position not too far in front, but not too far back, either. When the Goldilocks Effect® went into play we didn’t have to wait very long for the show to begin. There was no opening act and in fact, it started a bit earlier than the 8 p.m. door time printed on the tickets. Bowie came right out and asked the audience if they wanted a long set or a short set. Well, you could imagine the audience response. What we could not have imagined then was the band’s response.
DAVID BOWIE | Earthling Tour @ The Chili Pepper – Ft. Lauderdale | OCT 8, 1997
- Dead Man Walking (Acoustic)
- I’m Waiting for the Man
- Always Crashing in the Same Car
- The Supermen
- My Death
- The Jean Genie
- I’m Afraid of Americans
- Strangers When We Meet
- The Hearts Filthy Lesson
- Seven Years in Tibet
- Looking for Satellites
- Under Pressure
- Hallo Spaceboy
- Scary Monsters (And Super Creeps)
- Little Wonder
- Panic in Detroit
- The Voyeur of Utter Destruction (As Beauty)
- The Last Thing You Should Do
- V-2 Schneider
- Battle for Britain (The Letter)
- O Superman
- White Light/White Heat
- Moonage Daydream
- Queen Bitch
- I Can’t Read
- Telling Lies
- Look Back in Anger
- Fame (Is It Any Wonder version)
- Pallas Athena
- The Man Who Sold the World
- All the Young Dudes
Feast your mind on that three and a half hour set list! That’s not a concert; that’s a boxed set! Main set in black. Encore #1 in red. Encore #2 in blue. It opened with an acoustic version of the one song that was immediately appealing from “Earthling” and went straight into a “Hunky Dory” deep cut before covering The Velvet Underground and pulling a “Low” deep cut out of their hat as if by magic. The immediate effect was to prepare one for anything and everything, which, is exactly how it played out by evening’s end. Only “Fame” and “Fashion” were from the “Sound + Vision” tour setlist. The rest was shot through with a sense of both history and adventure as Bowie’s four piece band tackled deep cuts and modern material with aplomb. Better still, nothing from the “double-breasted dumbness of the mid-80s*” was within miles of the stage that night.
* a very useful quote from John Foxx…
The band that night was the same one that we had seen on the Outside Tour two years earlier. If it was a real gift getting to see Mike Garson play in an intimate environment like this one, then the effect of seeing Bowie relate to his audience and the music in a space where he was only 25 feet in front of you was a revelation. The human scale of the show was the furthest thing from the hit-the-marks professionalism of the earlier shows I’d caught in 1990 and 1995. As adequate as they were, they were acts of commerce strained through the art filter. This, instead, was an act of communion and good fellowship. It was radically different seeing David Bowie really having a good time at his own show.
The concert started out acoustic and low energy to work up to a frenzied pace by the end of the first set. The music morphed from acoustic rock into art rock before taking off toward the drum and bass that had informed his latest album. When it peaked with “Little Wonder” the band left the stage but told us that it was only a “bathroom break.” Sure enough, they were back in a minute or two and began the first encore with my favorite “Aladdin Sane” song, “Panic In Detroit.” I was surprised to hear “V-2 Schneider” even in its compromised Dao Jones Index version, but what really seemed unprecedented that evening was the excellent cover version the band did of Laurie Anderson’s “O Superman.” When the laughing loop started off the song, I was thinking “it can’t be…” but it was. Bassist Gail Ann Dorsey held the lead vocals; giving her the lead mic for the second time that night following her duet with Bowie on “Under Pressure.” The next two songs were a raucous “White Light/White Heat” followed by my favorite “Ziggy Stardust” track, “Moonage Daydream.” Not a song I could have ever imagined hearing! Surely that was the evenings end as the band exited the stage?
Not by a long shot! They were quickly back as they proceeded to play another ten tunes. I’d seen The P-Funk All Stars play a three hour set before but this was going to put even that into the shade. They opened with the vivacious “Queen Bitch” and managed to serve up a Tin Machine track that Bowie had really taken a shine to [“I Can’t Read”]. The one tune from the new album that taxed me live was the enervated “Telling Lies,” but that was followed by the always righteous “Look Back In Anger.” Another song that night I could not have imagined hearing was the taut and dynamic “Stay” from “stationtostation.” By 1997, the popularity of Nirvana’s cover of “The Man Who Sold The World” had given the song a new lease on life that managed to eclipse it’s old lease, so it was not a surprise to hear it out in the world. Finally, at thirty six songs in, the band gave up a killer All The Young Dudes” that managed to make us forget Mott The Hoople for once.
Then the band really did leave the stage but only after they had exhausted 36 of the 37 songs they had rehearsed for the Earthling tour. The only one that they did not play was “I’m Deranged” and the reports of those who had gotten there early enough to have snapped the photos that began this post revealed that they had played it during their soundcheck, so they might have gotten confused three hours into this marathon. One could forgive them for maybe thinking “didn’t we play ‘I’m Deranged’ already?” Besides, I had seen that performed on the Outside tour.
The fact is, that after the two hour mark, I was prepared for the show to end at any time and when it didn’t, each song played became akin to a special event of a sort. The thousand people in the sweaty confines of The Chili Pepper got to see the crack band doing excellent work and the guy with the biggest smile on his face of all was probably David Bowie himself. He had successfully achieved his aims of jettisoning his 80 world-straddeling pop baggage and integrated a set comprised almost 40/40 between 70s classics and deep cuts and his modern output; along with well-considered and surprising covers and experimentation like the “Is It Any Wonder” version of “Fame” filling in the cracks.
The next day we could still not believe what we had been given. My friend Elisa had never seen Bowie before [she also passed on the “Glass Spider” tour in 1987] in spite of being a huge fan, so that was her only show ever, but like the man says, it was the show to see if you’re only having one! After this concert, I only ever could have seen the “Reality” tour before all the live shows ended for Bowie. I don’t think I could have gone backwards in an arena of thousands of peopleoids with Bowie a small speck onstage trying his level best to project to a vast, dark amoeba of an audience. No, my history of Bowie concerts began large, and impersonal and by the last one, had concentrated their essence to become an impossibly intimate celebration of the best that Bowie had to offer with none of the false steps that had plagued the 80s. That it had been successful could be seen on the beaming face of the man himself.
Next: …What do you do the night after you were in a room with David Bowie’s band?
It’s pretty well known that you got the Brilliant Set. In NYC at The Supper Club, which I almost DIDN’T get into, we got just under 25 tracks but we did his version of O Superman which was, um, unexpected – and wonderful. I think he stripped away a few songs from the set list and the encore list by the time they got to NYC.
Echorich – Well, it certainly made up for never having him tour in Florida. If you read the link to the other blog, the fellow who wrote that was apparently a writer for Jam Magazine’s South Florida edition, and he was taking notes which had Bowie threatening to perform his longest show ever. I was too busy gawking at Bowie [and Gabrels and Garson, who was having a great time himself] who were about 25-30 ft. in front of me. 25 tracks is still nothing to sneeze at, mind ye.
Wow…had to read that setlist out to my wife. Her fandom came late and after she passed on a spare ticket for a show on the Reality tour that became spare after a friend broke his arm, while…arm wrestling, seriously! To say she regrets that would be a gross understatement.
The setlist for that gig was pretty great but not as long as this! I managed to get something like 12th row tickets in a 10000 capacity venue which made a big difference. £75 pounds on eBay at the time, ridiculous bargain with hindsight. But to imagine a gig in a 1000 capacity venue…amazing.
Bowie did some small gigs in the UK that year but for various reasons I wasn’t in a position to get to them. Again it was just before his transition from legend to, the horribly over used term, icon. Meaning that any future gigs would be sold out in 2 seconds to organised touts!
Pingback: Second Chance For Bowie’s “Brilliant Live Adventures” 1990s Live Sets | Post-Punk Monk
This is me, killing myself for having missed that show.
Unless there’s a boot of it somewhere …
chasinvictoria – Nooooo! Don’t kill yourself! Uh, now that I think of it why weren’t you there??!! We had the ticket for Bev and she didn’t end up going but why was one of my top Bowiecentric friends [you vs Elisa – who will win?] not there too? Beyond the fact that my car only had room for 4.
Pingback: “Moonage Daydream” Finds New Ways To ‘Dance About Architecture’ | Post-Punk Monk