Record Review: B.E.F. – Dark | Music of Quality + Distinction Vol. 3 [part 2]


A “well chuffed” Martyn Ware has achieved genius on the new B.E.F. album…

When I was just a tad, I can recall hearing “It Was A Very Good Year” by Frank Sinatra a lot. It was one of the first songs that I can recall hearing, along with “Can’t Take My Eyes Off Of You” by Frankie Valli. I was always struck by the maudlin, depressing qualities of the tune; even as a child. The sense of death approaching was palpable in the Sinatra version to my youthful ears. Now we have Glenn Gregory taking on the tune, and his performance sounds more reflective and somewhat celebratory to me, but that just might be my 49 year old ears making a difference.

Gregory offers a compassionate take on the lyric with yet another great performance on the record. I’m less convinced with the backing track. Following the first verse, it’s an ambient hip hop soundbed with a shuffle beat and vinyl crackle aplenty. The style is not the problem for me. It’s the tempo. It sounds like Gregory is singling to a different tempo than the beat that has been used in the song. When I try to sing along* it’s well nigh impossible to match Gregory on beat. Weird. But his performance is excellent, no matter what difficulties I have in listening to it.

* C’mon. You do it too.

The driving, intense take on Iggy Pop’s “I Wanna Be You Dog” by Boy George was pre-released as a taster for the album and I’ve already noted that few would recognize the former Culture Club crooner on this stygian powerhouse of a tune. As noted, he recalls the attack of Nick Cave far more than anyone would expect from the man who sang “Do You Really Wanna Hurt Me.”

Though this Monk has been around the block as many as three times, he hasn’t seen or heard it all. Not yet.  I had not heard approximately a third of these songs previously. All of them are excellent songs, so hats off to Martyn Ware for curating this collection. One particularly stunning song is “The Same Love That Made Me Laugh” by Sheffield singer David J. Roch. I’d not heard of him but even the Bill Withers tune from 1974 he sings was new to my ears. His performance is spine tingling as the song begins over piano chords with deep sustain. His vocals are doubled at just the threshold of hearing in a whisper that almost sounds like a binaural recording. Subtle and thrilling stuff! Then the Eurobeat begins and the song enters Moroder-space. As much as I love that approach, I almost prefer the original two minutes of the song, but the contrast is fascinating, and it doesn’t take away the spellbinding intro movement to this song.

Shingai Shoniwa is a new name to me since I don’t get out of my Record Cell too much. But like Kate Jackson, I will think about looking into her band The Noisettes since her vocals on the venerable “God Only Knows” are full of magnificent character and I’m ready for more. This is a singer who brings an insouciant swing to the Brian Wilson number and you just know that Martyn and the other backing vocalists [Billie Godfrey and Kelly Barnes of H17 fame] had a ball harmonizing on some radically different backing vocals than they normally indulge in.

Boy George was back for a version of Lou Reed’s “Make Up” from the “Transformer” album. This makes two songs from that record that have appeared on two volumes of MQ+D, so this must have had a big impact on the young Mr. Ware. It’s not too much of a head stretch to imagine Boy George singing this one, but I’d not heard him since “The Crying Game” and I wasn’t prepared for the “grain” he’s acquired in the course of his tumultuous life. But he fits the number warmly and with a backing track not far removed from the original, that puts the spotlight on his dusky, now seriously lived in vocals.

Last month, Sandie Shaw abruptly retired from performing, but thank goodness she had already laid down her vocals in this smoking version of Gladys Knight’s “Walk In My Shoes!” This was another song I’d managed to miss in my years on planet earth, but it doesn’t matter. Ms. Shaw positively bites the lyric, which radiates passion and hurt, like the pro she is and the backing track synthesizes Motown and Phil Spector in a whizzing synthetic cocktail that comes the closest to reflecting the sound of the first MQ+D volume.

As far as hitting the target that Ware was aiming at, I don’t think there’s a song on this album that isn’t more spot on than Polly Scattergood’s haunting take on “The Look Of Love.” It’s definitely a “dark take on a previously happy song.” I can’t say that it works for me, personally. Scattergood’s tremulous, near whisper on the song has the queasy whiff of a woman in a sadomasochistic relationship. This perception isn’t exactly dissuaded by the music bed, which sounds like Michel Legrand meets David Lynch. Then it turns atonal and ghostly on the fadeout. Brrrrr!

Thank goodness, that the next cut comes when it does. Billy MacKenzie was a good friend to Ware and Gregory and since his tragic death in 1997 prevented him from participating here, Ware does the next best thing and includes Glenn Gregory singing Billy’s biggest hit, the electric “Party Fears Two.” This cut, in fact, appeared on the last H17 album, the strange odds + sods collection “Naked As Advertised,” but Ware reasoned that few probably heard that release, and it deserved a wider airing. To say the least! They reimagine the jaunty song here as a heart-rending ballad at a glacial pace that significantly heightens the poignance hidden deep within the number. Stellar.

The first song here that seeded this entire project was Billie Godfrey’s cover of Bronski Beat’s “Smalltown Boy.” It’s a widescreen take on the previously intimate cut. Godfrey has been singing with Heaven 17 ever since their first tour following “Bigger Than America.” While I can no appreciate the song without hearing Jimmy Somerville singing, the arrangement echoes the one on the Bill Withers song with David Roche in that the buildup is slowly paced before the beat marches in, except that this time it’s over 60% of the long 6:30-ish running time. One gets the impression that the song’s fabric may have been stretched a wee bit thin to fit comfortably on that framework. Always leave ’em wanting more; that’s my motto.

The album wraps up with “bonus tracks,” whatever that means. Maxim is a Russian pop singer who worships at the altar of synthpop, so naturally he struck up a  friendship with Ware. Together they reinterpret the ABBA classic, “The Day Before You Came.” The song is such a sturdy construction, it more than supports the warm synthpop/klezmer fusion that Ware offers Maxim as support. The end result is one of the lighter moments on the album that nonetheless confirms the songwriting genius of Bjorn and Benny.

Finally, Heaven 17’s other backing vocalist got a platform to step up to the front here. Ware gave Kelly Barnes Teena Marie’s “Co-Pilot To Pilot” to cover since he felt her voice resembled Teena’s. You might say! I’m not familiar with the track in question, but I certainly thought she was very close to the late Lady T. When I sampled the original, I was floored at the similarities, vocally at least. The B.E.F. squad have let the dogs out of the house and this track is all about H17’s backing band, Tim Cansfield [guitars] and Randy Hope-Taylor [basses, keys]. The extremely funky rendition makes Teena Marie’s sound pretty thin. Taylor’s deeply flanged bass is solidly in the Bootsy Collins Zone, and the closest I’ve ever heard to Star-Mon® himself! Needless to say, this is my wife’s favorite track here!

This album was years in the gestation but it solidly paid off to these fervent ears [and eyes]. I’d be remiss if I didn’t point out how gorgeous and evocative Malcolm Garrett’s exquisite cover design is as well. The CD looks dark and seductive; a perfect complement to the music inside! The album itself takes an approach halfway between the extremes of the previous Volumes 1 and 2 in this series to strike a solid synthesis of synthpop and R&B/funk influences while leaning towards a film music influence. In fact, disc two of this edition of the CD, which features the backing tracks in instrumental form, is subtitled “Soundtracks for Imaginary Films” right on the disc itself. I’m guessing that Ware made it with an eye towards getting sone soundtrack work. The irony is, that it’s far too effective a calling card for his production career!

After this hit the streets, I wouldn’t be surprised if there were stars beating a path to his door in the hopes that he night produce their albums. After all, this is the man who sold millions for Terrence Trent-D’arby and pulled Tina Turner from the doldrums and re-energized her career. This album is so hot [Polly Scattergood excepting; I can’t go there] that I’ve not been able to give the instrumental disc a listen just yet after over a week of listening. It is flat out the best cover album I have heard since Icehouse gave us “The Berlin Tapes.” Martyn Ware is clearly a man at the top of his form here. I’m not shocked that he was able to shop this to the Wall Of Sound label on completion; making him labelmates with The Human League yet again!

It proffers a wide variety of singers giving their all in a selection of top drawer material that includes several definitive takes on what are some very familiar songs. That songs and singers I’ve not yet heard can send goosebumps down my arms upon initial listening reveals that Ware and his B.E.F. team have outdone themselves this outing. I have already had multiple numbers from this release lodged in my skull to powerful effect, and it’s the sort of album that can be heavily played for a year, with new “favorites” rising to pole position on the iPod® of my mind.

– 30 –

About postpunkmonk

graphic design | software UI design | media design • record collector • satire • non-fiction
This entry was posted in Core Collection, Record Review and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Record Review: B.E.F. – Dark | Music of Quality + Distinction Vol. 3 [part 2]

  1. Echorich says:

    Martyn and David Roche provide us with the “Billy Mackenzie Moment” on MQD3. ‘Same Love’ is stirring and each time I hear it I know this is the track that Martyn would have wanted BM to interpret. As I said before, the approving persona of Billy Mackenzie looms large and approvingly over this album.
    I really enjoy the miss-timed vocal/backing of It Was A Very Good Year. There’s a sort of defiant individualism about Glenn’s vocals as if he is purposely ignoring where the music is going. At the same time I feel this is one of the most HL Mk 1 reminiscent tracks on the album.
    In a conversation I had with one of my oldest friends back in NYC about the album we both came to the conclusion that Polly Scattergood’s The Look Of Love is one of the stand out moments on the album. I mentioned to her that I knew the reinterpretation wasn’t for everyone, but we concluded that it was actually quite stirring in its sterility. It’s like a whisper from a woman about to murder her sleeping lover – quite evocative.
    I really enjoy both of Boy George’s contributions and agree that his voice has a real “life lived” quality to it. As much as his reading of Make Up pretty amazing, I was left wondering what kind of a wonderful Weimar Cabaret feel that Marc Almond might have provided.
    Glenn/H17’s take on Party Fears Two is so emotional and touching. The Associates track had a nervous, paranoid feel to it, but Glenn takes the song to a height to show it’s beauty and how it stands head an shoulders above much of the pop music that came out 30 odd years ago.

    This is a masterpiece for which all concerned should hold their heads very high. Martyn is a production king. The instrumental cd shows just how much he understands sound and it’s ability to create vision.


    • postpunkmonk says:

      Echorich – Yes, Billy looms large over “Dark” in more ways than one! Glenn slays me with “It Was A Very Good Year” and even though the arrangement is almost deliberately maddening [I’m getting better at singing along with it… but it’s hard] it still wins me over in a big way. It’s such a great song and I have nothing but accolades for his interpretation of it. As for Polly, I don’t see her as a murderess as much as the victim, who knows that she may die but can’t help it. Marc Almond on “Make Up;” good thought! I’d like to hear Marc on a MQ+D volume, if we’re ever lucky enough to get V. 4. We know and love the H17 PF2 cover. It’s a textbook case of perfection. This album gives me back waaaaaaaaay more than I paid for it. It’s my favorite MQ+D volume, and that’s even sitting on a packed CD of 77-ish minutes where the others were “normal” albums of 40 or so minutes. Wow! Usually I’ll always opt for the shorter program. But I guess Martyn doesn’t have time to waste since it took over 20 years to pull this one together. He won’t be doing volume 4 at 75! But if this is the last one, he’s gone out with a bang! I’m in such turmoil these days since I am pulled equally between the Visage album and this one and they arrived the same week! Both of those albums are “under my skin” and I can recall the exact running order of each, which is no mean feat for me.


  2. zoo says:

    I have to admit that I would probably not have given this album a listen without your comments, Monk. And while I can’t praise it as much as you and Echorich, I did enjoy listening to it (for the most part) on Spotify yesterday. The two Glenn Gregory tunes were excellent to my ears, as was “PIcture This” (though I felt it went on a bit too long). The others didn’t really stand out to me too much,. The only one that really bothered me was the Betty Boop version of “God Only Knows.” That song is one of the great achievements in pop music, IMO. I wouldn’t go so far to describe this version as irreverant, but too light-weight. Overall, though, I’m glad I listened!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.